I feel that we need more admins. I hate to say this, but most of the admins we have now, I can't really trust. Also, they don't seem to edit much. >_> Plus, there have been times when we needed an admin, and they were nowhere to be found. 4 just isn't enough. :s
I'm not a huge fan of the layout. I agree with Gleek; the Duncan and Lindsay layout was so awesome.
When it comes to banning, I think the admins are verrrrry slow on that. Look at how long it took them to finally ban so many people.
The most important thing to me is that the regular users don't seem to be involved. At times, it feels like a dictatorship. The users don't get a lot of say in what's going on.